Score: 3

"Could have been... better..."

submission: The Nerd Test V3.2

date: January 9, 2009

The good:
It correctly interpreted i was a nerd.
The falling particles.

The bad:
The music is more annoying then my sister.
The questions aren't completly on the little blocks.
Unoriginal.

My advice, study up on flash and release peices that have a more complete feel.

Score: 9

"Pretty great for a compilation."

submission: $00pah NiN10Doh!

date: January 8, 2009

Most compilations have got one or two great artists and the rest suck ass, while that is occasionally displayed here i can't really argue with it because of how long it was, longest flash i've seen on newgrounds... loaded in 30 secs which is a century to my usual on ng but then i looked at the size and well that explained it... Possibly having it load parts as it goes would be a better system for those with slow internet.

The good:
Length.
Variety.
Sheer WTF moments.

The bad: some of the voices and animating didn't feel like they suited each other, mind you jiggly puff sounded perfect...
size: 21 freaking megabytes, most of the downloads I do are smaller then that...

Overall: a great peice with its own little issues as all seem to have. 9/10 5/5. Size is the one thing that i kinda didn't like but also loved, No damn pixalation is worth 21 megs, however those still using dial up are in trouble. (who uses it any more anyway? got cable?)

kudos to the organizer for getting this big a collab together.

Score: 9

"Pretty good but could use some improvement."

submission: Rat Episode 2

date: January 1, 2009

First the bad things just to get them out of the way, The voice acting was slightly less then something expected... and I'm not sure exactly what the parameters you set for compressing the flashback segments, but raising the quality of that would help to improve the experience. there was some pixalation during that part, and you have 2 megs to work with... Yes i know i don't have a damn clue about the small details...

Now for the good which by far outstrips the bad, First but not least a frame by frame work, minimum tweaking if any style thing, love that, don't see enough of that. Secondly, while many will argue, I believe this is working up to revealing a slightly greater picture, we just have one or two corners of the big picture. And last but not least, You didn't go for this cheap shit some other people do, quality stayed steady through out the work* made me feel the next one will be even better.

All in all a great piece of work, could use some buffing but that's just extra onto the work of art. The only people I've see put down a bad score are the clueless and those who didn't bother watching the first one or who write like toddlers.

*see first paragraph for exception to that statement.